Independent agencies in St. Augustine
98 independent insurance agencies in St. Augustine. Independent agents shop multiple carriers to find coverage that fits you. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first; the complete directory stays alphabetical. Unclaimed listings are not endorsements; agencies can claim and verify their profile.
St. Augustine, FL market figures computed from public licensing records as of 2026. “Records” reflect each agency’s earliest entry in the licensing file — see how we source data.
Showing the first 24 as cards, and all 98 are listed below.
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2020 · NPN 19663018 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2015 · NPN 8834934 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2023 · NPN 20830120 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8910108 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2022 · NPN 17998749 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2019 · NPN 19230522 · public licensing record
St..Augustine, FL
In records since 2012 · NPN 16701294 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2019 · NPN 19176872 · public licensing record
St.. Augustine, FL
In records since 2022 · NPN 20352356 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2016 · NPN 17974525 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2026 · NPN 22096675 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2024 · NPN 21142752 · public licensing record
St.. Augustine, FL
In records since 2025 · NPN 15409331 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2018 · NPN 18760951 · public licensing record
St.. Augustine, FL
In records since 2012 · NPN 16784403 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2019 · NPN 19279822 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2024 · NPN 21299623 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2022 · NPN 20488172 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2017 · NPN 18572724 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2023 · NPN 21022936 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2014 · NPN 3651096 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 17731158 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8765869 · public licensing record
St. Augustine, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8919544 · public licensing record
All agencies in St. Augustine
- A To Z Solutions,
- A-Auto Insurance Agency
- A.M.N. Processing Inc Dba A.M.N. Financial and Insurance
- Accurate Insurnance Agency of ST Johns
- Adsum
- Alxa Insurance LLC
- Aponte Insurance Agency
- ARW Benefits, LLC
- ASK A Friend Inc Dba ASK Carol B
- Beaver Insurance Agency
- Belfast Blue Group Llc,
- Benefit Risk Advisors Dba Benefit Risk Advisors Insurance Agency
- Benefits By MSW & Associates, Inc
- Big Rig Trucking Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Bold City Insurance Concepts LLC
- Brandon Thomas Agency
- Brian Sesniak Insurance Llc.,
- Childress Insurance Brokerage,
- Compass Financial Services, LLC
- Convergent Financial Partners LLC Dba Convergent Insurance Partners
- Cowan Financial Group, Inc.
- Craig Dewhurst Agency Inc.
- Craig Funeral Home
- Dan Middleton & Associates, Inc.
- Danny Page Employee Benefits
- David Quinney
- Diaz Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Donald J Lohr
- Donald J Lohr, Pa, Inc
- Duncan Market Insurance
- Eberhart Insurance LLC
- FCR Consulting
- Fender Insurance Agency, LLC
- Firm Risk Consultants
- First Financial Education Centers, LLC
- First Florida Insurance of Jacksonville
- Florida Shield Agency LLC
- George Pascucci Insurance Agency
- Gilliland Insurance Group Inc
- Goat Insurance Partners, Inc.
- Grace and Mercy Financial,
- Hallett Insurance LLC
- Harbor Oak Insurance & Financial Services, LLC
- Hatcher and Associates Insurance, Inc.
- Insurance 1st East Coast Corp
- Insure Group Inc
- Insure Help, LLC
- Insured Financial Wealth LLC
- Insureous Health Solutions Inc
- James Allan Machmiller
- Janet Tillman Insurance Agency, Inc.
- JNZ Insurance Services Inc.
- June 12th LLC
- Kaitlyn Dugger Agency
- Kaitlyn Dugger Agency
- Ken Selmore & Associates, Inc.
- Kenneth H Greiner
- Knox Insurance Network Inc
- Kotrady - Hudgins - Croyle Funeral Home Dba St. Johns Family Insurance Agency
- Laws & Associates, Inc.
- Leigh Insurance Agency of St. Augustine Inc
- Lenoir Gillis Insurance
- Life & Health Associates, Inc
- Lite Speed Insurance Inc.
- Macmullen Consulting Group LLC
- Marshall Creek Insurance and Financial Services, Inc
- Mas Choices Inc
- Mayer Insurance Agency LLC
- Mcclure Benefit Administrators
- MFB Financial Dba the Bailey Group
- Middleton & Associates
- Milan D. Patel
- Millennial Specialty Insurance LLC
- Mladenovic Agency LLC
- Navigating the Retirement Red Zone LLC Dba Red Zone Insurance Planning
- Nefi Services, Inc. Dba North East Florida Insurance
- Norman Insurance Advisors, LLC
- OLD Town Insurance, LLC
- Page & Canova Inc.
- Perry D. Unwalla Insurance Agency, Inc
- Perry D. Unwalla Insurance Agency, Inc
- Philip D. Rogero
- Presta Insurance Group
- Prudential
- RBH Insurance LLC Dba Ancient City Insurance
- Rohill Insurance LLC Dba Packo Financial Group
- St. Augustine Insurance Brokers, LLC
- Tactical Insurance Solutions Inc
- The Bailey Financial Group Llc,
- The Polanco Group Inc
- Thompsonbaker Agency, Inc.
- Tim Huber Insurance and Financial Services Inc.
- Tire Shield, Inc.
- Totus Tuus Consulting, LLC
- Tpa Exchange
- Vienrich Insurance and Financial Services, LLC
- Ward Family Insurance Group, LLC
- Wolf Money Management
Living in St. Augustine
A quick look at the people and homes behind the St. Augustine insurance market.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates (2020-2024), for St. Augustine.
St. Augustine insurance, answered.
- How many independent insurance agencies are in St. Augustine, FL?
- Public licensing records list 98 active independent property & casualty agencies in St. Augustine, Florida, 20 of which have records going back 20 or more years.
- What kinds of insurance can agencies in St. Augustine help with?
- 4 of the listed agencies hold full property & casualty authority, covering personal lines (home, auto, renters, condo, flood, umbrella) and business coverage. A licensed agent confirms what they actually write before any quote.
- Are these St. Augustine agencies vetted or ranked?
- Listings come from public licensing records. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first, while the complete directory stays alphabetical. Preferred status is not an endorsement and does not change license verification. Agencies can claim their profile to add their website and details.
Nearby in St. Johns County
Source: Public licensing records: Texas DOI (Socrata) + Florida DFS bulk file; Iowa open data (CC-BY 4.0) for contact enrichment. Ordering: labeled Preferred Agencies first, then alphabetical. How we source data
Find Independent Insurance is operated by Relay and is not an insurance agency, broker, or carrier. We do not provide quotes, insurance advice, or coverage recommendations, and we do not guarantee coverage or price. Licensed independent agencies handle quotes, advice, and policy placement.