How many independent insurance agencies are in Middletown, NY?

Public licensing records list 2 active independent property & casualty agencies in Middletown, New York.

What kinds of insurance can agencies in Middletown help with?

Lines vary by agency, and some public licensing records don't designate specific lines. A licensed agent confirms what they actually write before any quote.

Are these Middletown agencies vetted or ranked?

Listings come from public licensing records. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first, while the complete directory stays alphabetical. Preferred status is not an endorsement and does not change license verification. Agencies can claim their profile to add their website and details.

Orange County · New York

Independent agencies in Middletown

2 independent insurance agencies in Middletown. Independent agents shop multiple carriers to find coverage that fits you. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first; the complete directory stays alphabetical. Unclaimed listings are not endorsements; agencies can claim and verify their profile.

Request quotes

The Manhattan skyline glows under a warm sunset sky viewed across the East River from Brooklyn Bridge Park.

New York

2independent agencies listed

Middletown, NY market figures computed from public licensing records as of 2026. “Records” reflect each agency’s earliest entry in the licensing file — see how we source data.

Affinity Advantage Inc.

Middletown, NY

Unclaimed

In records since 2017 · NPN 8284826 · public licensing record

View profile Claim this profile

The Premium Select Group Inc,

Middletown, NY

Unclaimed

In records since 2022 · NPN 16246754 · public licensing record

View profile Claim this profile

Living in Middletown

A quick look at the people and homes behind the Middletown insurance market.

30,289residents

9,970households

52%of homes owner-occupied

$308,600median home value

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates (2020-2024), for Middletown.

Middletown insurance, answered.

How many independent insurance agencies are in Middletown, NY?: Public licensing records list 2 active independent property & casualty agencies in Middletown, New York.
What kinds of insurance can agencies in Middletown help with?: Lines vary by agency, and some public licensing records don't designate specific lines. A licensed agent confirms what they actually write before any quote.
Are these Middletown agencies vetted or ranked?: Listings come from public licensing records. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first, while the complete directory stays alphabetical. Preferred status is not an endorsement and does not change license verification. Agencies can claim their profile to add their website and details.

Nearby in Orange County

Monroe (14)New Windsor (7)Newburgh (4)Goshen (3)Central Valley (2)Campbell Hall (2)Salisbury Mills (1)Washingtonville (1)

Source: Public licensing records: Texas DOI (Socrata) + Florida DFS bulk file; Iowa open data (CC-BY 4.0) for contact enrichment. Ordering: labeled Preferred Agencies first, then alphabetical. How we source data

Find Independent Insurance is operated by Relay and is not an insurance agency, broker, or carrier. We do not provide quotes, insurance advice, or coverage recommendations, and we do not guarantee coverage or price. Licensed independent agencies handle quotes, advice, and policy placement.