Independent agencies in Worthington

12 independent insurance businesses in Worthington, listed from public licensing records and shown alphabetically. Unclaimed listings are not endorsements — agencies can claim and verify their profile.

12independent agencies listed
4with 20+ year records
5serving businesses too

Worthington, OH market figures computed from public licensing records as of 2026. “Records” reflect each agency’s earliest entry in the licensing file — see how we source data.

Unclaimed

In records since 2010 · NPN 15913448 · public licensing record

Unclaimed
HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2006 · NPN 2425403 · public licensing record

Unclaimed

In records since 2008 · NPN 10097638 · public licensing record

HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2006 · NPN 7963385 · public licensing record

Unclaimed

In records since 2006 · NPN 2444086 · public licensing record

HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2012 · NPN 1702148 · public licensing record

In records since 2016 · NPN 8327624 · public licensing record

Unclaimed

In records since 2023 · NPN 9560641 · public licensing record

Unclaimed
HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2006 · NPN 1702198 · public licensing record

Paul C Carbetta

Worthington, OH

Unclaimed

In records since 2013 · NPN 17047470 · public licensing record

Yoloh Inc

Worthington, OH

Unclaimed
HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2023 · NPN 20742935 · public licensing record

Unclaimed

In records since 2016 · NPN 17935890 · public licensing record

Worthington insurance, answered.

How many independent insurance agencies are in Worthington, OH?
Public licensing records list 12 active independent property & casualty agencies in Worthington, Ohio, 4 of which have records going back 20 or more years.
What kinds of insurance can agencies in Worthington help with?
5 of the listed agencies hold full property & casualty authority, covering personal lines (home, auto, renters, condo, flood, umbrella) and business coverage. A licensed agent confirms what they actually write before any quote.
Are these Worthington agencies vetted or ranked?
Listings come straight from public licensing records, shown alphabetically. No agency pays for placement, and an unclaimed listing is not an endorsement. Agencies can claim their profile to add their website and details.

Source: Public licensing records: Texas DOI (Socrata) + Florida DFS bulk file; Iowa open data (CC-BY 4.0) for contact enrichment. Ordering: alphabetical. How we source data

Find Independent Insurance is operated by Relay and is not an insurance agency, broker, or carrier. We do not provide quotes, insurance advice, or coverage recommendations, and we do not guarantee coverage or price. Licensed independent agencies handle quotes, advice, and policy placement.