Independent agencies in Tallahassee
255 independent insurance agencies in Tallahassee. Independent agents shop multiple carriers to find coverage that fits you. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first; the complete directory stays alphabetical. Unclaimed listings are not endorsements; agencies can claim and verify their profile.
Tallahassee, FL market figures computed from public licensing records as of 2026. “Records” reflect each agency’s earliest entry in the licensing file — see how we source data.
Showing the first 24 as cards, and all 255 are listed below.
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2012 · NPN 8096017 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2013 · NPN 3670847 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 14497258 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 17734613 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2024 · NPN 21206838 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2022 · NPN 20277636 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8095206 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2021 · NPN 19909944 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8784119 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 17736043 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8096450 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2021 · NPN 19805259 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2024 · NPN 21314204 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2015 · NPN 17475259 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8900852 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2022 · NPN 20405442 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2010 · NPN 16099710 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2012 · NPN 14494644 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2006 · NPN 8875307 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2023 · NPN 20784368 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2017 · NPN 18582115 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2012 · NPN 16515851 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2021 · NPN 19962694 · public licensing record
Tallahassee, FL
In records since 2026 · NPN 22126209 · public licensing record
All agencies in Tallahassee
- Adams Insurance, In.
- Affiliated Insurance Agency of Florida Inc
- Aflac
- Aflac
- Alisha Clayton Insurance Agency, Inc
- Alisha Dionne Clayton Agency
- ALL American Insurance of East Tallahassee, Inc.
- ALL Insurance Solutions, Inc
- Alliance Insurance Inc
- Allstate Insurance Company
- Altamonte / Longwood Insurance
- Anchor Insurance Services
- Andrea S. Cohen Insurance, LLC
- Andrew Jackson Insurance, LLC
- Angela Hearl Insurance
- Anhay Medina Insurance LLC
- ARD Insurance LLC
- Arnold Edward Waters
- Arrigoni Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Asset Insurance Solutions
- Austin Bass Agency
- Avant Financial Group, PL
- Avant Huston Financial Group, LLC
- Avant Huston Insurance Group, Llc,
- Azure Insurance Group Inc
- Baker-Harris Insurance Agency Inc
- Barnes Benefit Consultants LLC
- Barnes Capital Advisors, LLC
- Benefit Solutions
- Bill Reardon Insurance Agency Inc.
- Booth Financial Services, Inc.
- Bridges Insurance Agency
- Bridges Insurance Agency
- Brigit Drawdy Smallridge Agency, Inc
- Brigit Drawdy Smallridge Insurance and Financial Services, Inc
- Budget Notary Services, Inc.
- Butler-Vause Inc.
- Bwebber Enterprises, Inc Dba Webber & Terman Insur
- Bynum Brokerage / Consulting Group, Inc.
- Capital City Benefits Consulting, LLC
- Capital City Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Capital Insurance Agency
- Capital Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Capital Risk Management
- Cardaci Insurance Llc,
- Carlton W. Barham
- Castillo Insurance Consulting
- Chancy Insurance Inc
- Cheesborough Insurance Agency
- Chris Lewis Insurance Agency
- Cmac & Associates Inc Dba Greatflorida Insurance of Tallahassee
- Corey Tyre Insurance Agency Inc.
- Corporate & Estate Analysts Inc Dba American Insurance Services
- Cycap Insurance LLC % Cycap Holdings Inc Sole MBR
- Daniel Adams
- David M Williams Agency
- David Springer Insurance
- Davis-Roussel Tallahassee, LLC Dba North Florida Financial
- Deloach Insurance Services
- Demont Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Dentalplans.Com
- Dessi INS Agency
- Dick Duffy, Agent State Farm Insurance
- Dick Franklin Insurance
- Dodson Insurance LLC
- Douglas M. Croley , Inc. Dba Doug Croley Insurance Services
- Drexal Harris & Associates, Inc.
- Earl Bacon Agency, Inc.
- Edward Kimmel
- Edward M Laurienzo
- Elements Property Insurance Managers, LLC
- Emmanuel G Insurance Associates,
- Empire Financial, LLC
- Employee Benefits Consultants, Inc.
- Faia Member Services, Inc.
- Faircloth Insurance Agency - Tallahassee LLC
- Faircloth Insurance Agency-Woodville, LLC
- Faircloth-Pyle Agency
- FBMC Benefits Management, Inc. Dba 3mpwr Dba 3mpwr Enrollment Solutions Dba the Clemons Company
- Fda Services, Inc.
- Fed Legacy Insurance Corporation Dba Fed Legacy Insurance Agency
- Financial Partners of North Florida
- Firefighters Insurance Agency
- Fisher Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Florida Association of Insurance Agents, Inc.
- Florida Insurance Consultants, Inc
- Florida Preneed Services, LLC
- Florida Retail Federation Services, Inc.Dba FRF Insurance Agency
- Florida Sheriffs Employee Benefits Agency, LLC
- Florida Sheriffs Insurance Agency, LLC
- Franklin Insurance Agency, Inc
- FRF Biz Solutions, LLC Dba FRF Benefits
- Fryson Insurance Group LLC
- Fuba, LLC
- Fuqua Insurance Agency
- G. Ron Krell and Associates
- Gayla L Parks
- Global Construction Insurance and Risk Services, LLC
- Goat Mindset, LLC
- Goode Financial,
- Goosehead Insurance Agency Holtom Agency
- Graganella Insurance Agency Inc
- Great Florida of Tallahassee
- Greensmart Financials Group, LLC
- Gulf Coast Benefits, Inc
- Hamrick Group LLC
- Harold Delee Dickey
- Hendrickson Insurance Services, Inc.
- HG Managing Agency LLC
- HMC Insurance Professionals
- Hodges Insurance Services LLC
- HP Managing Agency, LLC
- HP Risk Solutions, LLC
- Hub Public Risk Inc
- Iia Llc,
- Independent Market Solutions, LLC
- Insurance Innovations, LLC
- Insurance One
- Insurance One, Inc.
- Invest IT Rite, LLC
- Invictus Underwriters, LLC
- J Cheney Insurance Inc
- Jackson Financial Group, Inc
- James Campbell & Associates
- James Theron Cox
- Jaydee Insurance Agency Inc
- Jdm, LLC
- Jeff ARD Insurance Llc,
- Jeffrey Thomas Bolling
- Jennifer Nash
- Jim Smith Insurance Agency,llc
- John S. Olson, C.L.U. Inc.
- Jordan Insurance Services LLC
- Jurisco, Inc.
- Karen Sikelo
- Ken and Cheryl Bryan, Inc. D/B/A Bryan Insurance Agency
- Kimmel Insurance & Investments LLC
- Kuttin-Metis Wealth Management
- L&L Community Business Center Srvcs.
- Laffitte Financial Services
- Landon Seymour Insurance Agency, Inc
- Lee Cherry Insurance Sales
- Lee Harvey Insurance Agency,llc
- Leverage
- Life Solutions, P.A.
- Limcangco Insurance Agency, Inc
- Marks Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Marshall D Roberts Inc
- Matthew Jones Wheeler Agency
- Maureen Oneal Insurance Inc.
- Mcclenny Financial Group LLC Dba Mcclenny Insurance Services
- Mcginniss Himmel Insurance Agency LLC
- Mckee Insurance Agency LLC
- Mcnally Financial Services Corporation
- Messer Insurance Group LLC
- Messer Insurance Group, Inc.
- Michael A. Bell
- Michael Frantz Insurance Agency
- Michael Frantz Insurance Agency Inc
- Michael Jonathan Perez Agency
- Midtown P&C, LLC
- Miriam C Watkins
- Mobley Financial Services
- Nathan Lee Degraaf, Agency
- Nations Insurance Group
- North Florida Agents Network Inc
- North Florida Insurance Specialists, Inc.
- Notary Public of America
- Notary Public Underwriters, Inc.
- Oelerich Ins.Agency,inc.
- Olson Insurance & Financial Services, Inc.
- Oxford Connection Insurance and Financial Services, LLC
- Pafford Insurance Inc. D/B/A Quality Insurance of Tallahassee
- Peter G Catsimpiris Agency
- Peter G. Catsimpiris Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Phil Young Insurance
- Philip R Spitzer
- Pichard Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Poppell Financial Group
- Preferred Managing Agency, LLC
- Preferred Risk Group LLC
- Premier Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Preservation Financial Group
- Private Wealth Management Consulting LLC
- Proper Insurance Advisors
- Proper Wealth
- Prudential Financial
- Quality Financial Group,llc
- Randal E. Gassman Financial
- Randall Jones Insurance
- Red Hills Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Redhills Insurance, LLC
- Richard Smith & Associates, Inc
- Robert Kenon ,jr.
- Robert P. Toolan
- Rogers, Gunter, Vaughn Insurance, Inc.
- Royal Administration Services, Inc Dba Royal Hexagon Insurance Agency
- Rusty Hunt Insurance Agency Inc.
- Ryno Capital Advisors Inc
- Sagesure Insurance Managers LLC
- Samuel Grubbs
- Scott Reardon Agency
- Signature Group Financial Advising
- Sonlight Insurance Agency LLC
- Southeast Health Advisors Dba Southeast Health Advisors Insurance Agency
- Southern Asset Management, Pa
- Southern Benefit Solutions LLC
- Southern Capital LLC
- Southern Fidelity Managing Agency
- Southern Financial Insurance Group, LLC
- Southern Insurance Associates, LLC
- Southside Insurance Agency
- Spiegel Insurance Services
- Star & Shield Insurance Services LLC Dba Star & Shield Insurance
- Star-Line Insurance Agency, Inc.
- State Securities Corp.
- Steel Peach, LLC
- Step Four Consulting Group Inc
- Steve Halsell Dba Halsell Financial Solutions
- Strategic Benefits Group, LLC
- Supreme Life Insurance
- Synergy Wealth Solutions, LLC
- Tallahassee Financial Advisors
- Tann Insurance
- The Davino Agency, Inc,
- The Gabor Agency Inc Dba Gabor Financial Solutions
- The Gelabert Benefits Group Inc
- The Insurance Center
- The Jeffrey ARD Insurance Agency
- The Jeffrey ARD Insurance Agency,
- The Millionaire Portfolio Group
- Thurmond, Smith Insurance Inc., Dba Greatflorida Insurance of Tallahassee II
- Tiffany Surles Corporation
- Titan Funeral Company LLC Dba Titan Insurance Agency
- Trent Jones Insurance, Llc,
- Trey Laffitte
- Troy Fain Insurance, Inc.
- Trusted Funeral Plans, Inc.
- Tucker-Mills Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Ty Wehrs Insurance Agency
- Tyre Agency
- Tyson Insurance
- United Association Services Inc
- United Badges Insurance Services LLC
- United Group Programs, Inc
- United Insurance Company of America
- V. Catsimpiris Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Wanda G. Schilb
- Waterhouse Insurance, LLC
- Wealth Management Corporation
- William Joseph Zottoli
- Winchester Financial Group
- Wmdurham Associates LLC
- Woodham Insurance
- Yield Inc.
Living in Tallahassee
A quick look at the people and homes behind the Tallahassee insurance market.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates (2020-2024), for Tallahassee.
Tallahassee insurance, answered.
- How many independent insurance agencies are in Tallahassee, FL?
- Public licensing records list 255 active independent property & casualty agencies in Tallahassee, Florida, 78 of which have records going back 20 or more years.
- What kinds of insurance can agencies in Tallahassee help with?
- 8 of the listed agencies hold full property & casualty authority, covering personal lines (home, auto, renters, condo, flood, umbrella) and business coverage. A licensed agent confirms what they actually write before any quote.
- Are these Tallahassee agencies vetted or ranked?
- Listings come from public licensing records. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first, while the complete directory stays alphabetical. Preferred status is not an endorsement and does not change license verification. Agencies can claim their profile to add their website and details.
Nearby in Leon County
Source: Public licensing records: Texas DOI (Socrata) + Florida DFS bulk file; Iowa open data (CC-BY 4.0) for contact enrichment. Ordering: labeled Preferred Agencies first, then alphabetical. How we source data
Find Independent Insurance is operated by Relay and is not an insurance agency, broker, or carrier. We do not provide quotes, insurance advice, or coverage recommendations, and we do not guarantee coverage or price. Licensed independent agencies handle quotes, advice, and policy placement.