Independent agencies in Columbus
87 independent insurance agencies in Columbus. Independent agents shop multiple carriers to find coverage that fits you. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first; the complete directory stays alphabetical. Unclaimed listings are not endorsements; agencies can claim and verify their profile.
Columbus, OH market figures computed from public licensing records as of 2026. “Records” reflect each agency’s earliest entry in the licensing file — see how we source data.
Showing the first 24 as cards, and all 87 are listed below.
Columbus, OH
In records since 2018 · NPN 18922671 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2006 · NPN 14494433 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2017 · NPN 17351041 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2006 · NPN 17731996 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2025 · NPN 21554500 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2016 · NPN 3243797 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2022 · NPN 18099922 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2018 · NPN 18806940 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2022 · NPN 5698361 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2022 · NPN 3243827 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2024 · NPN 21030528 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2018 · NPN 8699865 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2012 · NPN 16293405 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2019 · NPN 17424231 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2024 · NPN 2516503 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2018 · NPN 18414580 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2025 · NPN 21741916 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2020 · NPN 2212406 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2006 · NPN 1875845 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2023 · NPN 2342562 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2006 · NPN 17733646 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2021 · NPN 18801114 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2022 · NPN 19770551 · public licensing record
Columbus, OH
In records since 2006 · NPN 16423 · public licensing record
All agencies in Columbus
- Absolute Insurance Solutions, Inc
- Albert James Marteney
- Alta Vista Benefits, LLC
- Antolino & Associates, Inc.
- Aspire Insurance Group, LLC
- Associates Insurance Services
- Beam Insurance Services Llc,
- Branch Financial Inc
- Broad Street Brokerage Insurance Agency Llc,
- Brokernet Inc,
- C2gi Dba C2gi Insurance
- Cambridge Insurance Group LLC
- Cardinal Financial Advisers LLC
- Catanzaro Insurance LLC
- Ciads Agency, Inc.
- Compare Quote LLC
- CTC Benefits HQ LLC
- Danduran & Associates Insurance Agency Inc
- Defusco & Associates Ins. Inc.
- Dehan Entprs INS & Fin SVS Agcy LLC
- Don Greco Associates
- Drury Insurance Llc,
- Dugan Brown Llc,
- DVM Insurance Agency
- Education First Credit Union Inc,
- Everich Group LLC Dba Secure Insurance Group Ohio
- Exact Benefits Group Llc,
- Finish Well Retirement LLC
- First Legacy Group,
- Fortress Insurance Group Llc,
- Foxen Insurance Agency LLC
- Francis Financial Services, LLC
- Frank and London Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Gardiner Allen Deroberts Insurance LLC
- Garlikov & Associates
- Germain Insurance
- Ha Agency LLC
- Hines Insurance Group,
- Hotel Insurance Group
- Huntington Insurance, Inc.
- Huntington Investment Company
- Independent Insurance Group Llc,
- Isner INS Assoc Inc
- Jason A Buehner
- John Kurgan
- Joseph William Moyer
- JZJ Insurance Services Inc.,
- Lauterbach & Eilber Inc
- Logan and Menning Advisors
- Lower Insurance, LLC
- Lynn Insurance Group, LLC
- Matic Insurance Services Inc.
- Michael Rothstein
- Nationwide Financial General Agency, Inc.
- Oh-Ins, LLC
- Omni Financial Securities, Inc.
- P R Hurlbut
- Paul W. Ward, Jr. & Associates, Inc.
- Peak Retirement Planning Inc Dba Peak Retirement and Insurance Planning
- Protex Insurance Group, LLC
- Puzzle House Insurance Group Llc,
- Ray Insurance Agency Inc
- Richard E. Connolly & Associates, Inc.
- Robert Crouch Insurance, Llc,
- Rockhill Underwriting Management LLC
- Rommel Angulo Insurance LLC
- Root Insurance Agency LLC
- Rwa Insurance Agency, LLC
- Secure Path Advisory Group, Inc.
- Shedenhelm Financial Concepts Inc,
- Slyman Insurance Group Inc
- Soller Insurance Agency, Inc.
- Stephen M. Roeder
- Surety Support Services, LLC Dba SSS Insurance Agency
- Sylvia A Garrett Insurance Agency LLC
- Telhio Insurance Services, Llc,
- The Taxman Agency Ohio, LLC
- The Thomas Fenner Woods Agency, Inc.
- The Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agency Kap LLC
- The W.E. Davis Insurance Agency, Inc.
- The Worksite Group Llc,
- True Wealth Financial LLC Dba True Wealth Financial Life and Health Insurance LLC
- Ultimate Services Agency LLC
- William D Clark Llc,
- William H. Meyer Agency
- Williams Insurance & Consulting Llc,
- Willis Towers Watson Midwest, Inc.
Living in Columbus
A quick look at the people and homes behind the Columbus insurance market.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates (2020-2024), for Columbus.
Columbus insurance, answered.
- How many independent insurance agencies are in Columbus, OH?
- Public licensing records list 87 active independent property & casualty agencies in Columbus, Ohio, 22 of which have records going back 20 or more years.
- What kinds of insurance can agencies in Columbus help with?
- 29 of the listed agencies hold full property & casualty authority, covering personal lines (home, auto, renters, condo, flood, umbrella) and business coverage. A licensed agent confirms what they actually write before any quote.
- Are these Columbus agencies vetted or ranked?
- Listings come from public licensing records. Featured cards show clearly labeled paid Preferred Agencies first, while the complete directory stays alphabetical. Preferred status is not an endorsement and does not change license verification. Agencies can claim their profile to add their website and details.
Nearby in Franklin County
Source: Public licensing records: Texas DOI (Socrata) + Florida DFS bulk file; Iowa open data (CC-BY 4.0) for contact enrichment. Ordering: labeled Preferred Agencies first, then alphabetical. How we source data
Find Independent Insurance is operated by Relay and is not an insurance agency, broker, or carrier. We do not provide quotes, insurance advice, or coverage recommendations, and we do not guarantee coverage or price. Licensed independent agencies handle quotes, advice, and policy placement.