Find Independent Insurance
New York

Insurance in Suffolk County.

423 independent agencies listed across 89 communities, from public licensing records.

Request quotes
423independent agencies listed
75with 20+ year records
104serving businesses too

Suffolk County, NY market figures computed from public licensing records as of 2026. “Records” reflect each agency’s earliest entry in the licensing file — see how we source data.

Communities

Places in Suffolk.

Melville (113)Hauppauge (33)Huntington (32)Smithtown (15)Commack (14)Bohemia (13)Farmingdale (10)Islandia (9)Sayville (8)Babylon (8)Patchogue (8)Huntington Station (7)West Islip (5)Southampton (5)Riverhead (5)Nesconset (5)Amityville (4)Ronkonkoma (4)East Setauket (4)Bay Shore (4)Northport (4)Deer Park (4)Holbrook (4)Holtsville (4)Port Jefferson Station (4)Kings Park (3)West Babylon (3)Stony Brook (3)Lake Grove (3)Dix Hills (3)Medford (3)Bayshore (2)Farmingville (2)East Hampton (2)Centereach (2)East Northport (2)Mattituck (2)Rocky Point (2)Calverton (2)Islip Terrace (2)Aquebogue (2)Centerport (2)East Islip (2)Lake Ronkonkoma (2)Center Moriches (2)Lindenhurst (2)Oakdale (2)St. James (2)Coram (2)Hampton Bays (2)Islip (2)Miller Place (2)Bayport (1)Port Jefferson Sta (1)Middle Island (1)Blue Point (1)Bridgehampton (1)Bellport (1)Patchoque (1)Setauket (1)Bay Point (1)E Northport (1)Halesite (1)East Quogue (1)Roslyn Heights (1)Cold Spring Harbor (1)W Islip (1)West Sayville (1)Pt Jefferson Station (1)Valley Stream (1)Plainview (1)Shirley (1)Melvielle (1)So Setauket (1)Fort Salonga (1)Ridge (1)Brightwaters (1)Water Mill (1)Mt. Sinai (1)Central Islip (1)Baiting Hollow (1)Sag Harbor (1)Copiague (1)Hauppage (1)Mount Sinai (1)Ronkkonkoma (1)North Babylon (1)Selden (1)South Setauket (1)
Local agencies

Agencies in Suffolk.

Listed from public licensing records, shown alphabetically. Listings are not endorsements.

232 JJB Llc,

Melville, NY · Melville

Unclaimed

In records since 2021 · NPN 18612556 · public licensing record

View profileClaim this profile
A J Bonocore Agency Inc,

Huntington, NY · Huntington

Unclaimed

In records since 2021 · NPN 2013764 · public licensing record

View profileClaim this profile
A R Insurance Services Inc

Commack, NY · Commack

Unclaimed
HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2022 · NPN 17889276 · public licensing record

View profileClaim this profile
A Star Agency Inc

Medford, NY · Medford

Unclaimed

In records since 2022 · NPN 3269482 · public licensing record

View profileClaim this profile
A. C. Edwards, Inc.

Sayville, NY · Sayville

Unclaimed
HomeownersAutoRentersCondo / co-opCommercial

In records since 2007 · NPN 2004641 · public licensing record

View profileClaim this profile
ACC Agency, Inc.

Melville, NY · Melville

Unclaimed

In records since 2018 · NPN 17822393 · public licensing record

View profileClaim this profile
Browse by community
By coverage

Browse coverage guides.

Homeowners · MelvilleAuto · MelvilleRenters · MelvilleCondo / co-op · MelvilleFlood · MelvilleUmbrella · Melville
Contractors · MelvilleRestaurants · MelvilleLandscapers · MelvilleCleaning · MelvilleLandlords · MelvilleRetail · MelvilleProfessional · MelvilleSalons · MelvilleAuto repair · MelvilleDaycares · Melville

Find Independent Insurance is operated by Relay and is not an insurance agency, broker, or carrier. We do not provide quotes, insurance advice, or coverage recommendations, and we do not guarantee coverage or price. Licensed independent agencies handle quotes, advice, and policy placement.